Cut gear stick?

  1. #1
    This may sound like a chav attempt of some sort or another, but would it be harmless to cut the original gear stick about an inch? I know it wouldn't shorten the throw etc, it's clearly for a shorter stick. I would just put an adaptor on the end of the stick to put my knob on, so would be the same i'd imagine?

    I just don't like the way it looks at the moment 2bh, it's got a aftermarket gaiter on it but it just looks long and thin. I would prefer it if the stick was shorter so that the gaiter can be a bit stumpy.

    Possible? I can't see anything wrong with it.

    A
  2. #2
    Yes you can cut the stick, it's a common cheap mod. Shouldn't have to many problems other than maybe a little bit of back ache.
  3. #3
    i did it at the weekend and its brilliant, and it has shortened the throw. I cut 40mm off. One of the best mods i have ever done.
  4. #4
    hmm might do mine, i have a spair anyway
  5. #5
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by VTEC-Saxo View Post
    hmm might do mine, i have a spair anyway
    seriously, ive had various quickshifts and none of them performed as good as just cutting the stick down.
  6. #6
    When i got my saxo its gear stick had been cut a bit and there where no problems but i replaced it with a standard one a couple of weeks ago cause it wasnt done well
  7. #7
    why the blue text is that a quote or what lol and j222jra i think im gonna then, did you take it off or just do it in the car with a hack saw lmao
  8. #8
    ive done it, i cut it just above the curve in the rod... id reccoemnd it, better than shot shiftes, and a free mod ...
  9. #9
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by VTEC-Saxo View Post
    why the blue text is that a quote or what lol and j222jra i think im gonna then, did you take it off or just do it in the car with a hack saw lmao
    haha I'll just stick to normal black writing then
  10. #10
    Wouldnt it feel like its a longer throw?

    I remember driving an old micra with a really long gear stick and the throw was tiny.
  11. #11
    mine feels awesome,i cut mine cuz some saft c*nt before me actually glued the knob on im mean lots of f*ckin glue
  12. #12
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by AlexGreen View Post
    Wouldnt it feel like its a longer throw?

    I remember driving an old micra with a really long gear stick and the throw was tiny.
    No by cutting it the throw will decrease, mine has by roughly 50%.
  13. #13
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by VTEC-Saxo View Post
    why the blue text is that a quote or what lol and j222jra i think im gonna then, did you take it off or just do it in the car with a hack saw lmao
    I had to fit a new stick so i did it before i fitted it. I cut it 20mm below the kink and then 20mm above the kink then welded the 2 bits together.

    I had to make the two cuts as a mk2 gear knob pushes on to a plastic adaptor on the stick and i didnt want to fit an after market one.
  14. #14
    mine has an after market and the douch who had it b4 glues . it has an adapter in it so it can be screwed on but they have taken the plastic off. how could i fit it ?? and by throw do you mean the distance between the movenment of your hand in gear changes??
  15. #15
    i could only imagen its a smaller throw tbh, iv got a aftermarket nob because mine was split, not fond but does the job think im gona cut it, like thesebmws with like 5 inch sticks! but sayign that the center buts higher up,
  16. #16
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by VTEC-Saxo View Post
    i could only imagen its a smaller throw tbh, iv got a aftermarket nob because mine was split, not fond but does the job think im gona cut it, like thesebmws with like 5 inch sticks! but sayign that the center buts higher up,
    Im sure you will be pleased with the results.
  17. #17
    the distance the top of the stick has to travel is reduced..... so in a way reducing the throw
  18. #18
    Why don't the 3 of you just GTFO my thread, and have a threesome!

    Back on topic.. Does anybody have a picture of how much shorter they're stick is?

    And also is it just about taking a hacksaw out to the car? Can't imagine why i'd have to take it out

    A
  19. #19
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by SaxoFurio1988 View Post
    Why don't the 3 of you just GTFO my thread, and have a threesome!

    Back on topic.. Does anybody have a picture of how much shorter they're stick is?

    And also is it just about taking a hacksaw out to the car? Can't imagine why i'd have to take it out

    A
    I had to take mine out because, mk2's have a silly adaptor on the stick that secures the gearknob on (it just pushes on) I didnt want to use an after market gearknob so i cut 40mm out of the stick and welded it back toghether.
  20. #20
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by J222JRA View Post
    I had to take mine out because, mk2's have a silly adaptor on the stick that secures the gearknob on (it just pushes on) I didnt want to use an after market gearknob so i cut 40mm out of the stick and welded it back toghether.
    It's a white thing isn't it? I got an aftermarket knob, so would i be right in saying tha i could just cut halfway down the white shaft and then apply the adaptors provided with the knob?

    A
  21. #21
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by SaxoFurio1988 View Post
    It's a white thing isn't it? I got an aftermarket knob, so would i be right in saying tha i could just cut halfway down the white shaft and then apply the adaptors provided with the knob?

    A
    yes mate your spot on!.
  22. #22
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by J222JRA View Post
    yes mate your spot on!.
    Sweet.. Will give it a bash!

    A
  23. #23
    are your adapters to fit straight onto a purly cylinder gear stick or a threaded one??
    as i still have trouble with mine.

    does the handbreak get in the way when its up?
  24. #24
    Cutting the stick does not reduce the throw, it might feel like it does but as your not actually changing the pivot point then the throw is exactly the same it just feels like its not.
  25. #25
    Ok, move your hand further down your gearstick, does you hand have to travel as far or less?

    It has definatly reduced the throw in my car.
  26. #26
    keep meaning to do mine, just need some blades for my saw!, i will take a little off and test it etc cause knowing me i will cut it to short!
    i have a spare anyway but its effort fitting them!
  27. #27
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by J222JRA View Post
    Ok, move your hand further down your gearstick, does you hand have to travel as far or less?

    It has definatly reduced the throw in my car.
    How far does the stick move below the pivot point which is the bit that moves the selector? That remains constant regardless of the length of the stick above the pivot point. So you may think its reduced the throw but the actual time to change and select a gear is exactly the same.
  28. #28
    Just think how short the gear change would be with the following -

    B&M Quickshift
    GE Quickshift
    Shortened gearstick
  29. #29
    I done mine earlier, and it's much better. I wouldn't say the throw is reduced or anything but it feels much more solid changing gears.

    I cut off just about under 2 inches.

    Will get pics up later, need to download LG PC suite

    A
  30. #30
    Heres a pic of my shortened gear stick for those that are interested.

  31. #31
    J222JRA- That looks mint. Does it not feel weird?
  32. #32
    Thanks mate it feels brilliant, it was something that i just decided to try and its that good i sold my compbrake and griff engineering quickshifts
  33. #33
    So did you just chop a few inches off of the top?
  34. #34
    How does the knob attatch and can you mount it back on easily?
  35. #35
    on a mk2, the gearknob pushes on to a plastic adaptor, so what i had to do is cut a 40mm section out of the stick and weld it back toghether. However if you didnt mind an after market gearknob you could just cut the top of the stick.

    PM me if you need any help
  36. #36
    Done mine today. What you think? Im pleased with it Cut about 2 inches off.



    A
  37. #37
    dunno if this dose anything to the gear change but i think it looks good, my mate did it in his 306 but the seats seem lower down and i dont think i could reach proper in my car so i aint doing it lol
  38. #38
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by wigansaxo View Post
    dunno if this dose anything to the gear change but i think it looks good, my mate did it in his 306 but the seats seem lower down and i dont think i could reach proper in my car so i aint doing it lol
    I didn't do it hoping it would reduce throw, it was intended for looks.

    I thought it might be a bit too low to reach but it honestly isn't.

    A
  39. #39
    As scott said it doesnt nothing to the gear changes.

    J222JRA - why have you sold your quickshift kits because cutting the stick down doesnt give you quickshift?
  40. #40
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by Elliott View Post
    As scott said it doesnt nothing to the gear changes.

    J222JRA - why have you sold your quickshift kits because cutting the stick down doesnt give you quickshift?
    Sold the quickshifts because the feel is no where near as good as with the shortened stick.

    This is just my personal opinion, it must be a in my imagination that the shift feels shorter.
  41. #41
    cut my gear stick by about 40mm, got to say im really happy with it def a lot more solid through the gears...
  42. #42
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by mrgris View Post
    cut my gear stick by about 40mm, got to say im really happy with it def a lot more solid through the gears...
    Couldn't agree more 2bh.

    A
  43. #43
    must be horrible to drive with a shortened gear stick, mines standard and low enough as it is!
    thinking about it, by shortening the amount before the pivot you reduce the amount of movement between gears(throw?) but increase effort needed to change
  44. #44
    im gonna do mine next week !
  45. #45
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by LeeM View Post
    must be horrible to drive with a shortened gear stick, mines standard and low enough as it is!
    thinking about it, by shortening the amount before the pivot you reduce the amount of movement between gears(throw?) but increase effort needed to change
    That was what i thought it would be like, but now ive done it, i wouldnt change it back its loads better.
  46. #46
    Looks like a lot of back ache changin gears tbh,
  47. #47
    1" inch or so off and it make a hell of a difference. easy gear change you just have to reach a little further to put into 1st gear.
  48. #48
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by Mattymcn View Post
    Looks like a lot of back ache changin gears tbh,
    im a short-arse in fairness so it doesnt affect me lol
  49. #49
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by J222JRA View Post
    im a short-arse in fairness so it doesnt affect me lol
    Me too... just 5ft 8"

    A
  50. #50
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by SaxoFurio1988 View Post
    Me too... just 5ft 8"

    A
    i dont care what anyone says been small is mint hehehe
  51. #51
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by J222JRA View Post
    i dont care what anyone says been small is mint hehehe
    Short asses ftw!!!

    A
  52. #52
    basicly cuting it down is like the feeling you would get if you were driving about and just holding it lower down, the pivot point still remains the same.

    Just because your hand is closer to the pivot point you dont have to move it asmuch as if it was further away, basicly it will increase ur shift time a fraction because your moving your hand less therefore going from gear to gear faster,

    It will reduce ur shift time a fair bit but will also increass the strain on ur hand

    ... not that you would notice atall because it is so little change
  53. #53
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by SaxSpeed View Post
    basicly cuting it down is like the feeling you would get if you were driving about and just holding it lower down, the pivot point still remains the same.

    Just because your hand is closer to the pivot point you dont have to move it asmuch as if it was further away, basicly it will increase ur shift time a fraction because your moving your hand less therefore going from gear to gear faster,

    It will reduce ur shift time a fair bit but will also increass the strain on ur hand

    ... not that you would notice atall because it is so little change
    Quote:
    25th March 2009
  54. #54
    what u on bout 24th of march??????

    there was no posts on this on that day
  55. #55
    I done this the other week because i got a new black leather knob, once on it seemed far to high up so i cut it down, i believe that it is such a good quick, cheap mod. Although i didnt write about it on here because i didnt think it would get as good a responce as it has got.
  56. #56
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by samfenna View Post
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by SaxSpeed View Post
    what u on bout 24th of march??????

    there was no posts on this on that day
    lol failed again....
  57. #57
    oooooooookkkkkkkkk thn :|
  58. #58
    this is a good cheap mod a think am gunna have a good at this soon like the pics to
  59. #59
    i fitted a quickshift and cut my down 60mm .then fitted new gear nob. i can change gear with a flick of the wrist now its brillant . it also looks good and is realy comtable
  60. #60
    I read this post after SaxSpeed resurrected the thread after a year and thought a quick and easy mod, so I gave it a go. I chopped 2" from the top of the stick and replaced the standard knob. I'm not sure about the quicker gear change as proclaimed by some others. Maybe its a placebo effect?
    What did feel weird was the first time I went for a drive, my hand went to the gear knob at its old height
    Now I've got used to it, it feels very comfortable. If you are thinking about it, try taking of half an inch or so, try it and then take more off if you want. Better than hacking off too much to start with and then regretting it.
  61. #61
    This reduces your shift time because the hand has
    less throw to reach the gears. As for reducing the throw, then no. There's a difference and people don't understand that. Also it is much more solid I.e a short bar has
    less resistance than a long bar.
  62. #62
    such a nice mod!
  63. #63
    Cut gearsticks ftw!!!!
  64. #64
    going to do mines tommorow or this week at somepoint
  65. #65
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by SaxSpeed View Post
    oooooooookkkkkkkkk thn :|
    lol look at the date properly 25th march 2009

    EDIT it is now 2010
  66. #66
    I imagine you all have track cars now?
  67. #67
    I certainly dont have a track car Tom lol............but cutting the stick made a massive difference, feels much better to drive imo
  68. #68
    Yer tbh i did it in one of my old spaxos. Seat bolted to the floor (im 6ft,2) then chopped the stick.
    Made it a better driving position and felt abit nicer. Especially when i lowered the steering column
  69. #69
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by Sparco_Tom View Post
    I imagine you all have track cars now?
    you always think the worst of people lol
  70. #70
    because im usually right
  71. #71
    i may try this also cheers boys
  72. #72
    After another commute today, I found that any gear change where the stick was brought backwards (ie 3rd to 4th, 5th to 4th), the change was quicker and smoother and just felt way more comfortable.
  73. #73
    always wanted to try this, was afraid incase the knob wouldnt secure on properly again thou
  74. #74
    I have a Mk1 and I just twisted and pull the gearknob off. When I put it back on, I wrapped some tape around the shaft, placed the knob in place and gave it a few whacks with a rubber mallet. This wedged the knob back in place, but not too much that I wouldn't be able to get it back off. I tried. No need for nasty glue. The gearknob feels tight and secure.
  75. #75
    I find it a stretch to reach the gearstick as it is. Then again, i am pretty short.
  76. #76
    can i do this on a mk1 but keep the original gear knob?
  77. #77
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by jono83 View Post
    can i do this on a mk1 but keep the original gear knob?
    Read up two posts from yours!!
  78. #78
    yeah i did......i wasnt sure if it was the factory he was talking about


    thanks
  79. #79
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by jono83 View Post
    yeah i did......i wasnt sure if it was the factory he was talking about


    thanks

    He was I and yes it is.